For everyone interested in the work of Britain's Parliament; the US Congress; the European Parliament and the French Parlement.
Discuss Practice, Procedure, History and current issues.
Tuesday, 15 March 2011
Primary and Secondary Legislation
Legislation can be classified as either Primary or Secondary (sometimes this latter may be described as 'delegated legislation'.)
In the United Kingdom Statutes (which may also be referred to as 'Acts of Parliament' - the terms are completely interchangeable) - are primary legislation. As "government" has become more complex, lawmakers have had to choose between getting all the rules in the Statute - the disadvantages being that Statutes would become incredbly long and difficult to read - let alone, understand - and Parliament would not have enough time to consider in detail all the provisions.
So it has become the norm that the principles and key rules are contained in the Statute. Lesser rules are not made and considered by Parliament - but the power is delegated to someone else. The advantages additionally include the fact that these secondary rulemakers may be more expert - or are closer to where the rules will apply.
At a national level powers may be delegated to Ministers.
s 11 of the Identity Documents Act 2010 says
(1)This section applies to an order under section 7(6) or 10(3)(i).
(2)An order is to be made by statutory instrument..
(3)An order may be made only if a draft of the statutory instrument containing it has been laid before, and approved by a resolution of, each House of Parliament..
(4)An order may contain incidental, supplemental, consequential or transitional provision..
s7(6) says "The Secretary of State may by order amend the definition of “identity document”" - without this provision any need to change the definition would require new legislation - which would have to go through all the stages of a bill in both Houses of Parliament. So Parliament has delegated the power to the Minister.
s11(2) states which form the secondary legislation must take - a 'statutory instrument'. All you could ever want to know about SI's can be found in the Government document available here.
The Parliamentary procedures for oversight of delegated legislation are described here. The most common procedures are the
Affirmative procedure: Both Houses of Parliament must expressly approve the SI. This may or might not involve a debate in the chambers - and the motion to approve might not be opposed - in which case no vote is taken. But when the motion comes up someone (often a whip) must should "aye" (Commons) or "content" (Lords)
Negative procedure: An SI becomes law without a debate or a vote, unless the delegated legislation is opposed. To do this an MP or Peer must "pray" against the SI. (Not on their knees, it merely means that they lay a motion to annul the SI)
I am a tutor for the Open University and have practical experience of working in the UK and European Parliaments.
Until May 2010 I worked at Westminster as Political Secretary to Lord Bach and to Lord Hunt of King's Heath. Previously I had worked as Research and Policy Director in the Office of Sir Peter Soulsby MP. In 2001 and 2005 I stood for Parliament in the South Leicestershire Constituency of Blaby. In 2009 I was a candidate for the European Parliament in the East Midlands Region.
I have a keen academic and practical interest in the workings of both the UK Parliament and the US Congress. I have made a number of study visits to Washington DC - and monitor proceedings, procedure and practice in the four chambers [House of Commons, House of Lords, House of Representative and the Senate]
Over the years I have broadcast on both UK & US Politics for BBC local radio including Radio Northampton; BBC Three Counties and BBC Radio Oxford.